Friday, November 5, 2010

Rome's Most Faithful Daughter

The author of Rome's Most Faithful Daughter: The Catholic Church and Independent Poland 1914-1939 Neal Pearse is a professor of history at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee. 

This is a very interesting book and a valuable contribution to the study of Catholic history in the first half of the 20th century, especially during the years immediately following World War I and the Russian Revolution.  From my perspective nearly a century later, with all the insights gained by hindsight, Pearse's unravelling of the multi-strand history of Poland resurgent in its great and grand complexities and with the hopes of popes resting upon it as bulwark of Christendom, makes for compelling reading.  To be quite blunt, I had no idea the Polish Second Republic was as riven with divisions in politics and religion - even within Catholic Poland - as it was.  Pease's examination of the role played by Marshal Jozef Pilsudski was enlightening.  When you consider the alternatives to the Marshal it is not surprising Rome spent much time and energy pulling the Polish bishops into line.  From my other perspective as a student of Holocaust and the Catholic responses to it, Pearse's book also helped me gain a greater appreciation of the Jewish-Christian realities before the German invasion.

Arthur Jones, book reviewer for the National Catholic Reporter wrote a very sound review of the book.  I agree with his assessment, but I have one criticism which I will mention after the review.

The Italian monsignor, Poland, God and church

Reviewed by ARTHUR JONES


By Neal Pease

Published by Ohio University Press, $26.95

It was Aug. 14, 1920. The Red army, determined on subduing the Polish army and regaining the third of Poland that Russia had only recently lost after 125 years, was roaring toward Warsaw. The country’s quick defeat was anticipated. The ambassadors of the major embassies had fled, leaving subordinates -- if anyone -- in charge. The Vatican had recommended its papal nuncio leave the doomed city.

Instead, the nuncio, Msgr. Achille Ratti (later Pius XI), had the papal flag run up the pole at the nunciature, ordered his open carriage, and was driven throughout the city to show everyone that he was still there. The last train carrying foreign officials was pulling out of Warsaw’s main station, Soviet cannonades could be heard in the suburbs, but Ratti -- who had sent out his archives with the English ambassador -- continued to let himself be seen. In addition to boosting the morale of the citizens, he wanted his conduct be known to the Polish fighters, 64 percent Roman Catholics, so they would know their church was standing with them.

Pope Pius XI, formerly Msgr. Achille RattiRatti’s conduct was risky, for as a priest and high Catholic dignitary, he could expect no mercy from the Soviet communists. The Polish head of state, Marshall Josef Pilsudski, also had left the city, but to take over command of the armed forces. Pilsudski implemented a daring maneuver to outflank the Red Army. On Aug. 16, he succeeded. The Soviets were routed.

To absolutely no one’s expectations, Pilsudski had saved Poland.

Equally, Ratti’s courage and conduct earned him the title Il Papa Polacco. He was the first of the Polish popes. Popes? Plural, you say?

Neal Pease’s minutely researched Rome’s Most Faithful Daughter is not just first-class political history earning its place among the best of the type. The book is part of Ohio University’s Polish and Polish-American studies series; Pease is a history professor at the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee.

It is a detailed recounting of the four-way dance between socialist leader Pilsudski, a Catholic nuncio who liked him and could overlook his peccadilloes, a right-wing Polish hierarchy that detested Pilsudski and did not entirely trust Ratti to seek Poland’s best interests, and a Vatican and papacy that needed its “most faithful daughter” far more than most people realized.

For a totally Eurocentric Vatican, which other continental European country in the first quarter of the 20th century had a majority population of pious Catholics? Where else in Europe was there a church still powerful enough nationally to have God and church written into its new constitution; its crowning national moments almost routinely celebrated in Catholic cathedrals by its heads of state and government?

Not France, “oldest daughter of the church,” with a Third Republic that saw French Catholics fleeing to French-speaking Canada. Not Germany, twisting down into the depths of an inflationary vortex that would spew up Hitler. Certainly not chaotic Italy, whose socialists were witnessing the birth pangs of Mussolini’s fascism.

A Reformation, and two revolutions -- the French and the Russian -- had spawned Europeans whose concepts of existence were not reliant, to put it mildly, on the church as their main reference point for their sociopolitical forms and opinions. Yet here was the newly constituted Catholic Poland, free and independent at last, after being divided into three parts and ruled for a century-and-a-quarter by Russia, Prussia and Austria.

Pease exhibits a master historian’s control as he interweaves these many strands of political history that impact the aspirations and exasperate all of the domestic political and hierarchical players.

The further benefit of Pease’s book is that from Poland’s past today’s readers begin to appreciate the extent to which pious and conformist, rightist and highly nationalistic Poland has influenced the papal mindsets and Catholic agenda since Pius XI’s day down to the present.

When Ratti was in Poland, Eugenio Pacelli (his successor, as Pius XII) was nuncio in Bavaria. As such, Pacelli was intricately involved in Germany’s claims on German-speaking Polish Silesia. Regarded as pro-German, Pacelli nonetheless understood and admired the Poles and apparently played by the book, diplomatically, where Polish interests were concerned. (The Poles remained dubious.) Ratti, as Pius XI, in 1923, sent Giovanni-Battista Montini (the future Paul VI) as nuncio to Poland. [Not quite accurate.  Montini was sent to Poland as a member of the nunciature staff, not as nuncio, for a short time in 1923.] As Paul VI, Montini pushed hard for permission to visit Poland under the communists, but was rebuffed.

Karol Wojtyla (as John Paul II) needs no further introduction. That brings the narrative to the present day and to the question: To what extent does Benedict XVI, who as Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger lived with the ethos and dictates of Polish Catholic thinking for 28 years, reflect that thinking other than in John Paul II’s hallmark Mary-centered piety? Ratti godfathered them all. (An amusing aside: The diplomat pope-to-be who declined the Polish post was Angelo Roncalli, later John XXIII. He went to Bulgaria instead.)

Pius XI was a reactionary autocrat, but whatever reservations one might have about him as pope, Achille Ratti is the hero of Pease’s superbly researched and highly enlightening book, and deservedly so.


My only concern is that there is little evidence of using material from the ASV related to Benedict XV or Pius XI.  I am not suggesting that Pease did not use material from ASV, only that the footnotes contain little reference to it.  This is disappointing.  Certainly a scholar of Pease's standing and clear ability should have, in my opinion, used this material explicitly.  Nonetheless, the book is well-written, easy to follow (itself reason enough to read it!) and does make a significant contribution to our understanding and appreciation of the Polish Church and its relations with both Rome and Warsaw.

No comments:

Post a Comment

You are welcome to post a comment. Please be respectful and address the issues, not the person. Comments are subject to moderation.