Showing posts with label Gabrielle Apor. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Gabrielle Apor. Show all posts

Thursday, October 3, 2013

Hungary June - September 1941 The Third Anti-Jewish Law

ADSS 6 references to Hungary traced the path of the Antisemitic Legislation approved by the Hungarian parliament and opposed by the Catholic bishops throughout 1939-1940.  Volume 8 of ADSS lets us trace the evolution of the next phase in the development of a Hungarian version of the Nuremberg Laws.  While it was true that Hungarian Jews were not being herded into ghettos and camps nor were they being murdered as part of state policy, their status in Hungary was now on a similar par with the Jews of Germany between 1935 and September 1941 when German Jews were ordered to wear the yellow star.

What ADSS shows is the intervention of Cardinal Serédi, in the Upper House of the Parliament attempting to if not prevent passage of the new bill then at least seeking to ameliorate those parts deemed contrary to the Catholic theology of marriage.

Act XV of the Hungarian Parliament in 1941, popularly known as the "Third Anti-Jewish Law" ended a process that had begun in 1938.  The law of 29.05.1938 began the removal of Jews from the professions and Hungarian economic life.  There were some exceptions, but the tone of future race-based legislation had been set.

Act IV of 1939 promulgated on 05.05.1939 defined Jews on racial grounds following the example of the Nuremberg Laws. Exclusion of Jews from the economic life of Hungary was accelerated.  A Hungarian form of "aryanisation" in the figure of the Strohmann (Straw Man) ensured that while Jews were forced out of management and public ownership, Jewish business expertise was not lost.  It was a cynical ploy, endorsed by the government, but allowed some measure of financial security for Jewish businesses.  At the same time an estimated 90,000 Hungarian Jews were unemployed, and by government decree, unemployable.  When the dependents of the 90,000 are added, the total number of Jews displaced by the new laws reached about 220,000 of a total population estimated at around 400,000.  This number was to grow rapidly to over 846,000 between 1939 - 1941 when Hungary was given tracts of territory from Slovakia, Romania and the defeated Yugoslavia.

The final law was debated in the Hungarian Parliament in July 1941.  This summary comes from the Hungarian website Social Conflict.

Act XV of 1941 (the third Anti-Jewish Law) on “The amendment and modification of marriage law XXXI of 1894, and the related necessary racial provisions” went into effect on August 8, 1941. Using Nazi terminology in its preamble, the law applied Germany’s Nuremberg laws: everyone with at least two grandparents born into the Israelite faith was defined as a Jew. The law also forbade marriage, and legally sanctioned extramarital sexual intercourse between Jews and non-Jews, provided the male was defined a Jew and the female was not. While the first two anti-Jewish pieces of legislation were accepted by Upper Chamber members representing Christian churches (Jusztinián Serédi, Catholic cardinal-primate, Sándor Raffay, Lutheran and László Ravasz Protestant bishops, as well as other church dignitaries), they strongly opposed the third law, as it drastically interfered with the marital status of converted Jews, thereby violating ecclesiastic jurisdiction.

ADSS 8: documents related to the passage of the Third Anti-Jewish Law in Hungary.

8.95    14.06.1941 Angelo Rotta, Nuncio to Hungary to Secretary of State, Cardinal Luigi Maglione.  Racial legislation in Hungary and the intervention of the Cardinal Serédi.

8.111  06.07.1941 Rotta to Maglione. 
Race laws in Hungary: opposition of the clergy and steps taken by the nuncio.

8.116  19.07.1941 Rotta to Maglione
Race Laws were approved by Hungarian parliament despite the opposition of the Catholic bishops and Protestant leaders.

8.120  26.07.1941 Rotta to Maglione
Race laws in Hungary approved without mitigation.

8.128  10.08.1941 Maglione to Gabriel Apor, Hungarian Ambassador to the Holy See.
Official Vatican protest against the race laws in Hungary.

8.130  13.08.1941 Maglione to Rotta
Protest against the new racial laws.  Implications for Catholic marriages.  Rotta replied 21.08.1941.  The law would be introduced gradually.

8.141 Gabriele Apor to Maglione.  Justification for the race laws.

Translations of these documents will follow in subsequent posts.  For the most part they do not need additional commentary.  The central theme throughout was the Church's protest against violations of traditional teaching on Catholic marriage, namely it was not the right of the state to legislate who could and who could not marry, outside of socially accepted norms that, in any case, the Church taught derived from Natural Law.  There does not appear any criticism of the removal of Jews from economic and professional life in Hungary.  This is not to say that the Catholic bishops of Hungary necessarily agreed with the removal of the Jews, but that in the documents presented in ADSS these concerns do not arise.  I admit this is the most positive "spin" I can put on the lack of evidence.

Sunday, September 4, 2011

ADSS 8.141 Gabrielle Apor's response to Cardinal Maglione's protest over changes to Hungary's marriage laws.

Following the previous post which set out Cardinal Maglione's protest to the Hungarian government, I present the reply written to Maglione by the Hungarian Minister to the Holy See, Gabrielle Apor.

Apor's response is couched in the customary diplomatic language, makes general and sweeping statements, vague and non-committal.  The Vatican was no threat as far as the Hungarian government was concerned.

Volume and Document Number: ADSS 8.141
Reference: without number (AES 7410/41, original)
Location and date: Rome 06.09.1941
Summary statement: Justification for the race laws in Hungary.
Language: French.

Text:

With reference to the letter of 13.08.1941 (1), I have the honour to communicate to Your Eminence:

The Hungarian Government has noted with sincere regret, the fears Your Eminence expressed about the reforms introduced in Hungarian marriage laws.

The Hungarian population is – as is generally known – divided into different religions. Therefore after 47 years the Hungarian State was required to regulate the institution of marriage by statue and introduce legislation to make civil marriage mandatory.

From 1894 the Hungarian government has been, therefore, consistently of the view that the regulation of the institution of marriage is a task for the state: the Hungarian Government has not – after that time – changed its point of view

Vital political interests of the country oblige the Hungarian Government to introduce into the marriage laws new prohibitive measures. These important interests which result as a consequence, in part, of the general European situation, in part special social conditions in Hungary, which have been raised several times by qualified representatives of the Government before the Parliament and expressed by the President of the Council [László von Bardossy] to His Excellency, the Apostolic Nuncio [Angelo Rotta].

During the discussion of the bill in question, the Hungarian Government sought to take account of the views expressed by His Excellency, the Apostolic Nuncio and His Eminence, the Cardinal Prince Primate [Justinian Seredi] to the extent that the political circumstances that have made reform inevitable, allowed them.

The Hungarian Government, on its part, assures the Holy See that the framework of the law will not lose sight of the considerations which the Church places, with great importance, when the law is promulgated and in its implementation.

The Hungarian Government would sincerely regret if these concessions were not entirely satisfactory to the Holy See, but it expresses the hope that this circumstance will not affect the friendly relations that have traditionally existed so well between the Holy See and Hungary since the time of our first king, St Stephen [King of Hungary 1000-1038]

ADSS 8.128 Cardinal Maglione's protest to Gabrielle Apor over the Hungarian race laws

When confronted with difficult situations the main avenue available to the Vatican was the diplomatic protest.  This case is from August 1941.  Throughout the war, the style of the official protest changed little.

When the Hungarian government of Laszlo Bardossy proposed and then presented changes to the marriage laws, outlawing marriage between Jews and non-Jews, Cardinal Maglione issued a formal protest to the Hungarian minister to the Holy See.  The protest is directed at potential violations of Catholic teaching on marriage which has an indirect appeal for Hungarian Jews. 

The language reflects not only the formal diplomatic use of the time, but the powerlessness of the Vatican to influence areas that would normally fall under its jurisdiction.  Maglione would have discussed the protest note with the Pope, and, as was Pius' manner, tried to word the note in such a way that the Hungarians would not be so offended as to consider a complete refusal to consider the Vatican's position.

The Hungarian response will be presented in the next post.

Volume and Document Number: ADSS 8.128

Reference: AES 6145/41 minute)
Location and date: Vatican City, 10.08.1941
Summary statement: Protest against the Hungarian race laws.
Language: French.

Text:

The Cardinal Secretary of State has the honour to communicate to His Excellency the Hungarian Minister [Gabrielle Apor] the following:

As soon as the Holy See learned that the Hungarian Government had presented bills on the marriage laws to the Parliament, it presented its concerns to the Hungarian Government in confidence through His Eminence, Cardinal Seredi, and also His Excellency the Minister and the Apostolic Nuncio in Budapest [Angelo Rotta].

The official projects concerning the obligatory medical examination before marriage and the defence of marriage between Jews and non-Jews, despite the explicit and legitimate opposition of the Catholic bishops of Hungary were, with minor changes, approved by the Parliament.

The Cardinal Secretary of State is obliged, therefore, to express to the Hungarian Government the concerns of the Holy See, with regard to respect for the Catholic doctrine of the sacrament of marriage.

The impact of the two proposals, if not felt immediately, will at least, indirectly, as a result of the civil act, which must precede the religious ceremony or lead to legal penalty, prevent the marriage. This is, properly, a matter for the Catholic Church.

It is only too evident that these two projects affect Catholic doctrine, in that they establish impediments to the celebration of marriage where neither the Law of God, nor ecclesiastical law have such restrictions.

The Cardinal Secretary of State, being forced to make these remarks to the Hungarian Minister, does however not wish to miss the opportunity to express confidence that the Hungarian Government would wish to introduce in the regulations related to the matter in question, mitigations and provisions that capable of satisfying the requirements of Catholic conscience.